
Originally published August 12-27, 2007.
©
2008 Worldwide
Recipes. All rights reserved.
It isn't absolutely necessary to begin a
discussion of dietary fiber with a review of diverticular disease,
but that's the way this one begins because it was a bout with
diverticulitis that inspired in me a curiosity about and a newfound
appreciation for dietary fiber. You can start your article on
dietary fiber any way you want - this is how I'm starting mine.
Attentive readers will recall that last
Saturday (that's August 4, 2007 for the benefit of future
historians) found me doubled over in pain in the emergency room of
my local hospital. The stomach cramps that had motivated my visit to
this place I rarely visit unless I absolutely have to were diagnosed
as diverticulitis, and after a detailed explanation of the
condition, its causes, and its remedies by the avuncular Doctor
Jordan, I was sent away with a prescription for oral antibiotics and
stomach cramps that were identical in every way to those I had when
I entered the hospital.
Fortunately the pains in my lower gut abated
after a couple of dosages of Ciproflaxin, thus allowing me to attain
something resembling an upright posture enough to sit at my computer
and do some internet-based research on the malady that had cut me
down. As I have said before, I like to learn something new every day
because, by the end of most days, I've usually forgotten two or
three things, and in the course of several hours spent at the
websites of several well known hospitals and medical schools, I
learned enough about diverticulitis to cover my quota of forgotten
things for at least a month or two.
The first thing I learned about
diverticulitis is that it has to do with things called diverticula
(that's the plural of diverticulum). These diverticula are abnormal
sacks or pouches that form on the outside of the lower intestine.
(Actually, they can form on many other organs as well, but it's the
ones on the lower intestine, or colon, that interest us here.)
Picture the bubble formed by a bicycle inner tube when it protrudes
through a hole in the tire and you have a pretty good idea of what
they are and how they are formed. The presence of these diverticula
constitutes a condition called diverticulosis, and when one of these
diverticula becomes infected or inflamed, that is the condition
known as diverticulitis. Collectively, all these things plus several
other complications are known as diverticular disease.
I was astonished to learn that in the United
States (which apparently is the world headquarters for diverticular
disease although it is also quite popular in England, Canada, and
Australia), diverticular disease is basically a man-made condition.
The disease was first recognized around 1900, and it is no
coincidence that refined wheat flour (i.e. flour with the fiber
removed) was introduced in industrialized nations around the same
time. The disease is rare in Asia and Africa where the typical diet
contains large amounts of fiber.
I was further astonished to learn that more
than 50 percent of Americans over the age of 60 have diverticula,
and that percentage increases with age. That's the bad news. The
good news is the majority of the people who have diverticula never
know it, and unless they experience a bout of diverticulitis like I
did, the likelihood is they will never be bothered by it.
My grandfather had diverticulosis for all of
the years that I knew him, and my mother and I recall very well the
many restrictions the condition placed on his diet and on the people
who cooked for him. After doing a little research I was astonished
yet again by how much of what I thought I knew about diverticulosis
was wrong.
When my grandfather was diagnosed with
diverticular disease over fifty years ago, his doctor made him swear
off a plethora of foods. He was told to reduce his fiber intake (in
those days it was referred to as "roughage"), so just about all
fruits and vegetables were on his list of foods to avoid. He was
specifically warned away from small seeds such as sesame, poppy, and
caraway seeds, and from fruits and vegetables containing small seeds
such as berries, tomatoes, peppers, and cucumbers. He was told to
steer clear of the skins of fruits and vegetables, all types of
nuts, and could eat beans only if they were strained to eliminate
the skins. As if this diet weren't limiting enough, he was further
cautioned that spices of all sorts could cause a relapse of his
condition. All of these things were considered potential
obstructions which could block or clog a diverticulum and cause
infection and inflammation.
I was greatly relieved to learn, upon
researching the latest medical thinking on the subject, that the
advice my grandfather received over fifty years ago was just as
outdated as you would expect fifty-year-old advice to be, and this
really came as no surprise to me.
What did come as a surprise was the number
of readers who, in writing to offer their sympathies because they
had also suffered from diverticular disease, revealed that they were
still receiving the same outdated, old-fashioned dietary advice that
my grandfather had received. I know that what I am about to tell you
will be met with skepticism by some, but if you'll bear with me I
will provide you with some unimpeachable sources to support what I
am going to say, so please hold off on sending your nastygrams until
you've read what the Mayo Clinic, the National Institutes of Health,
and others have to say on the subject. Please.
I'll get right to the point: the current
medical thinking is that there is no need to eliminate seeds
(sesame, poppy, caraway) or fruits and vegetables with small seeds
(berries, tomatoes, cucumbers) from your diet if you have suffered
an attack of diverticulitis and are trying to prevent a recurrence.
Ditto for nuts, skins of fruits and vegetables, and everything else
my poor grandfather was prohibited from eating for a large portion
of his life.
I know that many readers have been told
otherwise by their doctors, and I would never suggest that you
ignore your doctor's advice, but consider the possibility that your
doctor might not be 100 percent up-to-date on this matter. And
whatever you do, don't just take my word for it.
I urge my fellow diverticulitis sufferers to
do what I did and search for articles on the web using your favorite
search engine, and don't forget to put on your skeptic's hat when
judging the reliability and trustworthiness of the many articles you
will find. Personally, I'm a sucker for websites run by governmental
agencies, university medical schools, and famous hospitals when it
comes to medical advice. I am equally dubious of sites with names
like "Cleanse-Your-Colon.com" which also happen to sell some miracle
cure-all for every ailment my colon and I might one day experience.
Be your own judge, but please don't let yourself be misled by
websites that prey on the gullible.
The following websites are a few that I
found to have reliable, up-to-date, and unbiased information on
diverticular disease:
Diverticulitis - MayoClinic.com
Diverticulitis diet: Should I avoid nuts and seeds? - MayoClinic.com
Diverticulosis and Diverticulitis - National Digestive Diseases
Information Clearinghouse (National Institutes of Health)
Diverticulitis - Topic Overview - WebMD.com
Diverticulitis - Medline Plus Medical Encyclopedia (National
Institutes of Health)
I hope that readers interested in
diverticular disease for whatever reason will check out these
websites, and I also hope that they will use them as a starting
point for their own investigation into the causes and treatments of
the disease.
If you did your homework like good boys and
girls and reviewed the websites on diverticular disease that I
provided above, then you might have noticed the same thing I noticed
when I first began educating myself.
I learned that the principal reason that
diverticula form in the first place is a lack of sufficient fiber in
the diet. Insufficient dietary fiber also leads to the painful and
potentially dangerous inflammation of the diverticula known as
diverticulitis. The primary treatment for diverticulitis is usually
an increase in dietary fiber (although in some extreme cases your
doctor might recommend a liquid diet low in fiber in order to give
the large intestine a rest while it recuperates), and those of us
who are not eager to have a recurrence of diverticulitis are
encouraged to increase our intake of dietary fiber.
When I learned all this I scratched my head
and said to myself, "My goodness my gracious me. Dietary fiber seems
to be at the very root of diverticular disease. Fiber is not only
the single best remedy for this painful and debilitating condition,
but it is also the prophylactic measure prescribed to forestall
recurrences of this insidious gastrointestinal malady. I must begin
a thorough and detailed investigation of the role of fiber in the
diet forthwith."
Sheesh, I never realized I was such a
pedantic bombast even when talking to myself. Oh well. It is
befitting a grandiloquent and excessively florid examination of any
subject to begin with a definition of the matter at hand, and so I
will begin this examination of dietary fiber. Here is the definition
of dietary fiber offered by the American Association of Cereal
Chemists:
Dietary fiber is the edible parts of
plants or analogous carbohydrates that are resistant to
digestion and absorption in the human small intestine with
complete or partial fermentation in the large intestine. Dietary
fiber includes polysaccharides, oligosaccharides, lignin, and
associated plant substances. Dietary fibers promote beneficial
physiological effects including laxation, and/or blood
cholesterol attenuation, and/or blood glucose attenuation.
Whew, that's quite a mouthful, but there are
several important facts we can extract from this definition. First,
dietary fiber comes from plants, and only from plants. (Okay, so
there is some dietary fiber in mushrooms, and technically they're
fungi and not plants, but let's call them plants for now, okay?)
There is no dietary fiber in animal products such as meats, milk or
dairy products, or eggs. None. Not even a little. Period.
Second, the part about being "resistant to
digestion and absorption in the human small intestine" means that
they pass through our digestive system essentially unchanged. This
is why dietary fiber used to be called "bulk" and "roughage," and
you may still encounter those terms being used today.
Third, the part about "complete or partial
fermentation in the large intestine" means that bacteria that reside
happily in our large intestines are able to break down dietary fiber
to some degree even after our digestive system has given it its best
shot and failed, and some of the byproducts of this fermentation may
have significant health properties. More about this later.
Fourth, the business about "polysaccharides,
oligosaccharides, lignin, and associated plant substances" is pure
gobbledygook to me, so we'll just ignore that part.
Finally, the part about "laxation, and/or
blood cholesterol attenuation, and/or blood glucose attenuation" is
just a fancy way of saying that dietary fiber has health effects
that go beyond helping to prevent and protect against diverticular
disease as we have already discussed. We'll talk more about this
later, too.
So, now that we have carefully analyzed the
definition of dietary fiber, I'll bet you're still wondering just
what the heck it is. Am I right?
Okay, let's take this nice and slow. I think
that we all understand that dietary fiber is the parts of plants
that our bodies are unable to digest, right? Well, it turns out that
dietary fiber is divided into two categories: insoluble and soluble,
and all foods that come from plants contain a combination of both
these types of fiber in different proportions. Let's take a look at
both of them.
Insoluble fiber is the one most familiar to
us. It is the "roughage" and "bulk" that people usually think of
when they think of dietary fiber. Although there are many types of
insoluble fiber found in plant foods, the best known is cellulose,
and in addition to being a primary component of the plant foods we
eat, it is also the major component of grass clippings, sawdust, and
your favorite pair of denim jeans. It is indigestible even to
animals that rely on it for the majority of their diet including
ruminants such as cows and sheep, and only the activity of bacteria
in the digestive system prevents these animals from starving to
death on a diet composed primarily of cellulose and other insoluble
fibers.
Soluble fiber is a little harder to
visualize. It might help to note that another word for soluble fiber
is mucilage, and that one of the many compounds included in this
category of dietary fiber is a group of chemicals known as pectins,
the clear, gelatin-like compounds that make fruit jams and jellies
semi-solid. Rather than the tough chewiness characteristic of
insoluble fiber, soluble fiber is characterized by a slimy
consistency, and this property accounts for the slippery texture of
many foods that are high in soluble fiber such as oats and barley.
Now that we finally understand what dietary
fiber is, I bet you are asking, "Why the heck do we need fiber in
our diets?" I thought you would never ask.
Dietary fiber plays many important roles in
helping us stay healthy, and as you might expect, the different
types of fiber play very different roles.
Insoluble fiber adds bulk to the contents of
the intestines and helps move the byproducts of digestion rapidly
through the digestive tract. This provides a benefit in that some of
those byproducts are downright toxic, and the faster your body gets
rid of them, the better. A diet high in insoluble fiber also helps
reduce constipation, one of the factors contributing to diverticular
disease.
Soluble fiber tends to thicken the contents
of the intestines, thus slowing the formation and release of those
same nasty toxins. It also plays a role in preventing heart disease
and type 2 diabetes through some rather complicated chemical
processes. For our purpose, it is sufficient to think of it in terms
of the soluble fiber absorbing some of the cholesterol and sugar in
the foods we eat and allowing them to be excreted rather than
absorbed into the blood stream. (This is a gross over
simplification, but I'm just not smart enough to provide a more
technical explanation. Sorry about that.)
For many years dietary fiber was touted as a
preventative against colon cancer, but several large studies have
recently failed to demonstrate a link between colon cancer and fiber
intake. However, the other health benefits are well documented, and
just because a diet high in fiber will have little or no effect in
preventing colon cancer, there are still plenty of good reasons to
pay attention to your fiber consumption.
Speaking of fiber consumption, just how much
fiber are we supposed to consume anyway? The good news is that we
don't really need a heck of a lot of fiber in our diets to keep the
Fiber Police away from our doors. I mean, it's not like that old
myth about having to drink 8 glasses of water every day. (See "All
About Water" for more about that.) The bad news is, most of us
aren't getting enough.
Depending on gender and age, it is
recommended that most people consume between 21 and 38 grams of
total fiber per day. (For the amount recommended for you, see
this chart.) Unfortunately, the average American only consumes
about 12 grams per day, and unless you are a vegetarian or eat a
traditional African or Asian diet, the same is most likely true for
you regardless of where you live.
There are a few fairly simple strategies to
increase the amount of fiber in your diet, and I will elucidate
those in a minute, but I think one of the best ways to increase your
fiber intake is to learn more about the fiber content of various
foods so that you can take the reins of your diet and begin
increasing your fiber intake immediately. This is why I'm going to
do something I have never done before: I'm going to give you a
homework assignment.
Go to your favorite search engine and do a
search to see what information you can find on the fiber content of
various foods. Try to find a website or two that lists a large
number of foods along with their fiber content, and be sure to
bookmark them for future reference. See if you can find a list that
contains amounts of soluble and insoluble fiber as well if you want
extra credit. And remember, copying your neighbor's answer will get
you a visit to the principal's office.
One of the things I hope we learned from out
little homework assignment is that increasing our intake of dietary
fiber doesn't have to be the chore that some modifications to our
diet might be. For example, let's say that you really like artichoke
hearts, and in the process of doing some research into dietary fiber
on the internet you learned that artichoke hearts are very high in
fiber (they are, you know?) So now it's just a matter of eating more
artichoke hearts than you have in the past. There, wasn't that easy?
Here are some other easy strategies you can
use to increase your intake of dietary fiber:
- Switch to whole-grain breads and pastas
whenever possible. Eat brown rice instead of white rice, and eat
more whole grains such as wild rice, quinoa, barley, and oats. And
don't forget that corn in every form (except hominy or pozole) from
fresh on the cob to stoneground cornmeal is a whole grain, so eat
more polenta and cornbread.
- Eat more legumes of all kinds, including
beans, lentils, split peas, green peas, garbanzos, and peanuts.
- Snack on fresh fruits and vegetables
instead of potato chips and cookies.
- Eat a whole-grain cereal for breakfast,
but be sure to keep an eye on the rest of the ingredients. Just
because Lucky Charms are made with whole grains doesn't make them an
intelligent choice.
- Berries of all kinds, and especially
blackberries, raspberries, and strawberries are excellent sources of
fiber, so eat more of them.
- Ditto for dried fruits such as figs,
apricots, dates, raisins, and prunes.
- Nuts are a very good source of fiber, and
although they are high in "good" fats, it's still fat no matter how
you look at it, so eat them in moderation.
- All vegetables are rich in dietary fiber,
but leafy greens such as kale, collards, and spinach are especially
good sources. So are broccoli, Brussels sprouts, carrots, and beans
in their pods such as green beans (haricots), snow peas (mange
touts), and sugar snaps. All types of winter squashes are very high
in fiber, and onions and artichokes are especially high in soluble
fiber.
- The edible skins of fruits such as apples,
pears, plums, and peaches, and vegetables such as potatoes, sweet
potatoes, eggplants, tomatoes, cucumbers, and summer squash are
excellent sources of insoluble fiber, so you can stop peeling them
now.
Before we wrap up our discussion of dietary
fiber, I think now is the time to offer a couple of caveats.
As we have seen, dietary fiber is by
definition those parts of plants that pass through our digestive
system virtually untouched. Therefore, dietary fiber contributes no
calories to our diets and need not be considered by those who are
trying to lose or maintain weight by counting calories. (In fact,
consumption of fiber can result in a full feeling and might help
some people stick to their diets by reducing hunger.)
We should keep in mind that dietary fiber
(both the insoluble and soluble kinds) absorb water and prevent some
of it from entering the blood stream during digestion. Accordingly,
any increase in dietary fiber consumption should also be accompanied
by an increase in fluid intake. A diet high in fiber with
insufficient liquid in the digestive tract can result in
constipation, one of the things we are trying to avoid by eating
more fiber.
Nutritionists also recommend that, when
switching from a low-fiber diet to a high-fiber one, the change
should be done gradually in order to avoid taxing the digestive
system with a sudden increase in mass.
As long as we increase our intake of dietary
fiber in a reasonable and sensible manner, there is really very
little we have to watch out for. Obviously, if you switch to a diet
consisting of nothing but hay, you can expect to die from
malnutrition eventually if the intestinal blockage doesn't kill you
first, so I would strongly advise a consultation with your physician
before starting on an all-hay diet, or any other radical change in
your eating habits. In short, unless you are under doctor's orders
to limit the amount of fiber in your diet, the words to remember are
"fiber is our friend."
About all that remains to be said about
dietary fiber is the same thing I caution against in all my essays:
don't take my word for anything.
It's not that I would intentionally mislead
you. Au contraire, I go to great lengths to ensure that the
information I pass along to you in the form of my "All About" essays
is as reliable, accurate, and up to date as possible. However,
whenever I run across a pedantic bombast who is handing out free
advice, I hear whatever I... er, I mean "he" has to say with a
skeptical ear. I hope you do the same.
Please us the following links as a starting
point for your own investigations into the nature and importance of
dietary fiber. After you've studied up on the subject, I'm sure you
will agree that fiber is our friend.
Additional reading:
Fiber - Harvard School of Public Health
Nutrition Fact Sheet: Dietary Fiber - Northwestern University
Feinberg School of Medicine
Dietary
fiber: An essential part of a healthy diet - Mayo Clinic
High-Fiber Foods - Mayo Clinic
Fiber 101: Soluble Fiber vs Insoluble Fiber
Dietary Fiber
Database
|